this one feels like it kicks a bit more than this one) from normal shooting. Im also going to get some other angled grip for my offhand since thats the one which hurt more than my shooting hand. This package offers the Control Shield and Muzzle Brake as a bundle. Diameter(at largest point): 0.864 I measured how far the rig slid back for each shot. That makes no sense. The Titan is larger and heavier than the M4-72, but breathes less fire. On all four sides. Hey man, love your tests, been great info! Much to my surprise, Griffins M4SD Flash Comp beat the Hammer Comp on recoil reduction by 5%. Thanks, Thanks for this thorough review. The M4-72s performance wasconsistent with the previous shootouts, reducing recoil by 74.03%. Im betting that some of the comps that didnt do so well in the pure recoil tests will be found to be more effective where it counts : muzzle control. Finish:Ionbond CrCN, matte black The important stat is the recoil reduction as a percentage, which has proven pleasingly consistent.. Diamondheads T-Brake was a hot request in the comments of muzzle brake test #1 and #2, both here and on YouTube. They make it in both. It would suggest that all of the immense testing you already did might be inconclusive and possibly reopen the issue. This is why I never frequent indoor ranges. I enjoyed shooting the Super Redhawk in .44 mag I had, but it was about the limit of raw concussion I would prefer to expose myself to. From a physical standpoint, youll notice it is an extended version of the A2 flash hider found on the M16 and M4 series of rifles. It may not be a truly desired method of reducing recoil when youre talking about muzzle brakes, but it does correlate directly to real recoil reduction that you experience while shooting and I dont think its fair to tune it out. And there is the matter of reciprocating masses, which I realize, is a different, yet necessarily intwined matter. Were not a huge corporation that values the bottom line more than their customers and were not a one-man band selling AR15 parts out of a garage, were big enough to compete and small enough that each customer matters. How do you think, since youve tested so many muzzle brakes they get the price so low for a made in America part? Recoil test results for all of the entrants can be seen in the graphs and tables below. Choose Options. Diameter(at largest point): 0.901 Jeremy, great information and I liked that you did start mentioning about the side blast from some of these compensators. Though Im not really sure theres enough interest or enough difference between blast forwarding things to justify it. Ill probably do a linear comp/BFD when I build my AR-10 lower out. Machining is super clean, and, although I like to complain about a lack of wrench flats, the round ports that go straight through the BC-23 lend it particularly well to torquing via screwdriver. But if you remove the rearwards recoil, no shooter will show any muzzle rise itll just sit there totally steady. They look cool, but the blast is just. Rotating the sleeve exposes different baffle core ports and changes the direction of the expanding gasses, including through the small muzzle rise control vent on top (can be enlarged with a drill, if desired). This one being one of the worst offenders: http://www.thetruthaboutguns.com/2015/04/jeremy-s/gear-review-juggernaut-tactical-juggerbrake/. Cmon. Really interesting data here.great job!! Overall though its very good, and were it not for the close scrutiny of this test and the tough competition, it probably wouldnt be noticed. Since first appearing on the market in 2008, Xtreme Tactical Sports products have been recognized for their innovative designs, durability, and cost effectiveness. That said, there are also muzzle devices that do not fit into these categories. just skimmed over this but it seems as though the study fails to take into account vertical muzzle rise? Tiger Rock A2 Stainless Steel Muzzle Brake / Flash Hider This supremely affordable offering from Tiger Rock is billed as both a muzzle brake and flash hider. Please email me the details. Obviously this is easier said than done, as 90% of your body mass is below your shoulder line, so a rearwards push at the shoulder level is going to make a person lean back unless theyre in a proper stance/position. Weight:2.983 oz I believe the blast/wind from both of these brakes is approximately equivalent, but the Titan may have a little more concussion that your neighbors at the range will feel. The selection of the right muzzle device for your AR-15 can make a tremendous difference in its overall feel and performance. core15 muzzle brake Its a very compact, extremely lightweight compensator that truly surprised me with its recoil reduction performance. The WARCOMP is primarily a flash hider a pretty good one, at that but it adds a blast baffle / expansion chamber with circular ports to provide muzzle rise compensation and recoil reduction. Ill put a link in my profile I guess. Most people these days have never even shot an AR with the A2 .? I do not foresee a muzzle brake test where I focus on suppressor-accepting brakes. The large port presents a broad surface for gasses to impact against, which keeps the muzzle down and the sights on target. Have you tested a Lantac Dragon have not seen it in the recoil tests but saw one in the flash hider tests. Of all the devices I have installed on my ARs over the years, the one thing that has produced more audible wows than any other is an effective muzzle brake. As an engineer I know that theory, no matter how seemingly airtight, sometimes does not stand against empirical results. I, being a gunsmith, just think that lots of people overlook the thing that you allude to in your posting the fit of the firearm. No, no, no! This is a very attractive and well thought out flash hider that looks great once installed. New price $699 Dead Air Armament Sandman Ti Actually, it could be a lot of fun to build a mecha-themed rifle to match (yes, thats a challenge). If price is a factor in your decision and muzzle rise and recoil is not a concern, then there is no real harm with simply selecting a flash hider for your build. Im curious about the blast control/mitigation to see if they redirect the sound forward. .223/5.56 Muzzle Brake; Black Nitride Finish; 1/2X28 Thread Pitch; One Crush Washer Included Finish:bead blastor many Cerakote color options Material: stainless steel We did extensive research on the pressures the BFD could be exposed to in various rifle applications, and can do the same for any other application prior to working on specific mounting issues that may occur. Finish:black nitride Its small and looks pretty darn cool once installed. Length:2.25 It includes a crush washer. With the .454 Casull, .500 S&W Magnum and similar calibers gaining in popularity, theres a likely market for them, EDIT I realize a scope or rail would be required, iron sights would be out. Material: steel I stopped using it pretty fast. RAC em up! And sorry if this seems like a stupid question, but pretty new to shooting ARs as I just recently escaped an oppressive state that doesnt allow them. I swapped between some of the ones that caught my eye during that period) and I think my shoulder dyno is pretty decently calibrated haha. Length:1.808 As we saw in the .30 cal test, though, a good design is a good design, and relative performance carried over between calibers very closely. For that same reason, if youre building a high-quality, hard-use home defense firearm but do not have the ability to acquire a suppressor, then a flash hider is something wed most certainly recommend. Diameter(at largest point): 1.366 Even off a bipod taking precision shots at a few hundred yards, when the crosshair doesnt leave the target you can drill the snot out of the thing while seeing your own hits rather than fire then spend two seconds trying to find the target in your zoomed-in scope picture again. Anyway both of these things result in muzzle rise because the shooter is being pushed around by recoil. This brake should have been tumbled and/or media blasted after it was machined. CORE15 Rifle Systems .223/5.56 Muzzle Brake: My CORE15 brake loaner is well-used, but the nitride finish still looks great. Diameter(at largest point): 1.0 Finish:LifeCoat Seems like it would be kind of cool to do in conjunction with this, but I totally understand the logistics of it could be staggering at best. Cobalt Kinetics includes this brake on their EVOLVE Riflein a handful of different finishes. Diameter(at largest point): 0.74 Length:2.286 They are hybrids which attempt to both suppress flash and mitigate recoil. New price $90 Griffin Armament M4SD Flash Comp In the same way that a compensator helps you get back on target quickerso to can a muzzle brake. Again thanks for the videos and in depth reviews. It does this by venting gases to the rear, driving your AR forward in the process. ^^^^^^^. Dead/ Bad Links Lund/SJC .223 Titan Compensator, Link Update 3 of 3 But I also had the wrong lower on the gun. Diameter(at largest point): 0.94 Although that particular element of the law was struck down as it made muzzle breaks illegal rather then muzzle brakes.. I started looking for flash hiding/compensation. Indian Creek Design BFD While muzzle device blast shields and flash cans are nothing new in the shooting industry, The Indian Creek Design BFD (Blast Forwarding Device) is unique and unmatched in its ability to allow the user to utilize virtually ANY muzzle device from todays most popular muzzle brakes to the venerable A2 flash hider, and still be able to re-direct concussive forces that occur downrange. Seriously. Additionally, once you have a suppressor and a gun that accepts it you dont tend to shoot it unsuppressed a whole lot, eh? Also there is some interesting testing over here if you wanted to compare: https://precisionrifleblog.com/2015/08/21/muzzle-brake-summary-of-field-test-results/. sunwing travel agent near me; engraved name plates for urns. There will be a fourth test soon, but the Paladins wont be in it. Its no fluke, either. Armageddon Tactical CompTek Type I Compensator/Brake: Truly great machining and a flawless finish left me shocked when the CompTek refused to thread onto my rifle. Material: hardened steel Each muzzle device was timed properly, and tested twice. MSRP:$109.95. Even my minuscule Paladin 2 chamber taper mount brake makes a very noticeable difference on my SCAR 17S. Finish:raw Again, go golfing if you dont like noise or concussion blast from firearms! Well talk about those near the end of this article. Shall we buckle a lil safety pin on you? You FUDS are no better than the control freak liberals who are constantly demanding what people should or should not own, what size magazines they only need, or how no one needs machine gun or black rifle Hopefully soon it will be your disgusting type who will no longer be welcome at our firearm ranges. I fully agree with you; however in California I cannot have a flash hider, only a brake. At least on the first shot in a string, as both of them get significantly less fiery becoming basically equivalent on subsequent shots. Timing and tuning is done with the titanium sleeve, so no shims or crush washers are needed. Whats great about this flash hider is that when mounted per BATF specifications for a permanent installation, it will bring your 14.5 M4 barrel to a non-NFA length of over 16.1. A closed face and gas ports in the upward position help direct expelled gasses to control muzzle climb and improve follow up shots. Muzzle rise on an AR only happens because of rearwards recoil. Tactical Advantage Armory CC-23 Titanium Muzzle Brake: CC may stand for C-Comp or something, and I think its obvious from the side view why TAA may have called it that. Its also how its applied could be a very quick, sharp impulse and could be more of a push over time. The Cerakote job on my sample was done evenly and thoroughly, but the machining leaves something to be desired. For an aggressive, but not quite howitzer-like look, and for staying within size restrictions for some competition classes (although I believe in the U.S. its 1.0 thats used as a limit in some classes, meaning this one would technically be too big at 1.02), Nord Arms makes their Standard brake. The black oxide finish was done very well. I noticed in the comments that many mention about how these affect your neighbors on the range, but maybe there are some compensators that wont disturb your neighbor as much but will still help with accuracy. Muzzle Device Questions? Of course, there are still ways around it and honestly, Id prefer to tolerate the inconsiderate assholes as part of the price of freedom. Timing it is not necessary, as thats the job of the Ti sleeve, which goes on next. ODIN Works 5.56 Atlas Compensator The ATLAS is muzzle device that features a 3-piece modular design that makes installation simple and fast. Precision Armament AFAB-556 Hybrid Muzzle Brake: The AFAB is my go-to, all-around muzzle device, although in this crowd of highly effective brakes and comps its 50.55% recoil reduction seems less impressive than it really is. Clearly, a lot of people find the triangular shape compelling and wanted to know how the recoil reduction stacks up. But for 3 gun competitors that doesnt matter as much I guess. It seems like extremely high quality for the price point. Jeremy, Id be running it bare brake in all cases except for shooting next to other people or shooting indoors, in which case Id toss the shield on. Even if the weight is the reason the SJC wins, it still legitimately wins and if youre looking for the most recoil reduction possible then it comes out ahead. Finish:black oxide I like this suppressor a lot. It makes follow-up shots much, much easier. On the competitive side of the fence, we now see muzzle brakes which can act as compensators. Most physically efficient, basically, if weight is your determining factor in how effective a brakes design is. Which is basically the same as the one you tested. Diameter(at largest point): 0.866 Diameter(at largest point): 0.866 Dead/ Bad Links Kahntrol Solutions 3-Gun Brake Machining and Cerakoting are both very clean. Considering the huge, rearwards-angled baffles I figured this guy would be in the running for unseating the reigning champion but, alas, it was not to be. Material: steel (also available in stainless steel) Heck, it typically allows me to see my own impacts on steel targets, when otherwise my field of view would have immediately moved off the target upon firing. It just does so in a slightly different manner. Weight:1.118oz VG6 Precisions EPSILON 556 affords you the best muzzle control and recoil mitigation the industry has to offer. would be interested in seeing the results of some brakes that have a shield, like the Surefire Warden, will it increase the recoil? As always, if you have any questions about any of the muzzle devices weve listed here, please give us a call. For most casual shooters who are plinking 5.56 out of an AR, a compensator should not be absolutely necessary. Id certainly be using a muzzle brake if I was involved in any sort of competition with my AR. Machining and finish, like on the brake, is as good as it gets. No Change Phase 5 FATman Hex Brake Weight:3.15oz This is their Open brake, designed for competition classes that dont limit brake size. In the case of this test, two shots were fired with each brake while on the test rig (some were fired outside of the testing) and a handful of them appeared in the FH testing, too. Still good Black Dawn Muzzle Brake What a hoot. Plus, youre not limited to just paper targets. Maybe in the future you could do a battle of the cheapos, $50 or less, if someone else hasnt already. The Dirty Bird .30 5/8-24 A2 Birdcage Flash Hider is the classic A2 flash hider design but refined in key areas. core15 muzzle brake. Increase sight radius and such. MSRP:$79.95. I think its safe to say at this point that Muzzle Brake Shootout #4 is never happening. Recoil reduction performance is good, but nothing to write home about compared to other brakes of its size. I hate muzzle brakes, with a flaming passion. @Dyspeptic- Put me down for a signed copy of the book, Im a believer, and agree 100%. Well, it does have a column for MSRP. Seems to be you have an issue with free speech, son. Youre saving all of us lots of money by testing versus us guessing on a nice looking brake and then find out otherwise. Thanks for your help, and reviews! My local indoor range has five 100 yard rifle bays. Forum Rules and FAQ; Calendar; Forum Actions. The rifle I want already comes with a suppressor, but Im not even sure if it comes off. This compensator features a robust, cast design that is ideal for 3-gunners. The large port presents a broad surface for gasses to impact against, which keeps the muzzle down and the sights on target. Weight:2.637 oz Its a no-nonsense, high value option that is made of high-quality stainless steel, so it has natural corrosion resistance and durability. Weight:3.101oz That said, if youre diving into the world of competition shooting, where youre needing to rip off fast, accurate strings of fire and not wanting to deal with a rifle climbing on you, a compensator just might be the muzzle device for you. A hybrid device that has either advertised flash suppressing properties or functionally has flash suppressing properties would be deemed a flash suppressor. Diameter(at largest point): 0.951 doesnt need to be registered, can have a standard mag release.) They are hybrids which attempt to both suppress flash and mitigate recoil. Material: 17-4PH stainless steel Really? Weight:3.551oz Theyd reduce recoil more if the baffles were angled rearwards, but the shooter would absolutely pay for it in more blast, concussion, and volume, and people understand that. Regardless, this is a very good-looking, very effective compensator and like everything from Hiperfire, its both well thought out and not quite like anything else out there. Suppressor mount brakes are increasingly popular even with people who never intend to actually mount a suppressor for some reason(cool looking?). Ive had it for a few months and will be writing up a brief review soon, but the short version is that its great and I have nothing negative to say at all. Most notably, this design is no longer offered for 5.56 and is now most similar to their .30 caliber, 5/8-24 brake. Why are they not included in the second and third? brake is adorned with Picatinny rail. Finish:Cerakote (or similar) Yes, thats right. Quality is obviously quite high and it does look pretty badass. The Excel doc includes all of the length, width, weight, and cost data in addition to the results of each test in inches and as a percentage, etc. Weight:4.691oz (2.5 oz in titanium) Finish:black Dead/ Bad Links WeaponTech Punisher Compensator/Flash Hider Dyspeptic- I helped develop the Indian Creek Design BFD (blast forwarding device) that Jeremy S is testing. if you are, let me know and well send over some of the Indian Creek Design BFDs. No wrench flats, despite a perfect place for them. The more venting designed into those shields, the less effective theyll be at focusing blast, gas, pressure, noise, etc forwards but the more effective theyll be at compensating and/or reducing recoil. MSRP:$99. It produces strong, shockingly-repeatable results at very lost cost and complexity, but perfect it is not. Dismiss. It acts as a QD mount for KACs 5.56 suppressor line, and is a combination brake / comp / and flash hider. NBS Four-Pronged Flash Hider This muzzle device is a flash hider that features an aggressive profile with four prongs in the front, with four slots to redirect gas and blast. So if I want to sight something in real quick, or want to blow off some steam after work, I go to an indoor range, which has really made me hate muzzle brakes. But, the extra muzzle flash and explosion of firepower would definitely have soiled his panties!!! Tactical Advantage Armory NES-23 Titanium 3-Gun Compensator: Despite its decent size, the titanium NES-23 weighs only 1.65 ounces, making it feellike its made of air. Now if you are referring to someone who doesnt compete and has an obnoxiously loud brake at the local indoor range, well, I might agree, they they are quite possible an a-hole. Jeremy. MSRP:$69 and up. 1255 - City becomes ducal residence of Upper Bavaria. Length:3.372 Cheers-. Thanks P for the info. Diameter(at largest point): 0.952 I wasnt suggesting you tune it out across the whole field. With the exception of shooting in a speed-related competition where I want the best brake possible, I shoot suppressed. The slots up front allow the user to torque the recessed flash can without removing the Handguard. Machining and finish are awesome, and the look sets it apart. Material choice and machining are top quality. MSRP:$89.95. New price $89.00 Armageddon Tactical CompTek Type I Compensator/Brake Score one for logical thought processes. I wasnt expecting a lot of recoil-reducing performance, but cutting it by over 55% aint too shabby. MSRP: $94.95. Finish:black nitride on steel, sleeve left raw I just want to mention that the Venom Defense 3 chamber Comp is like $22-29 on their website right now So, that recoil reduction to price chart got even better. My only other option is to have the threads cut off and the barrel crowned (I have plenty of length) as the best solution. Expect a meaningless (~5%) reduction of recoil from it. Weight:4.198oz Length:3.258 1) train to shoot from a more stable position/stance so the torso doesnt get leaned back from recoil 2) hold the gun in a better location in the shoulder pocket or even over towards the pec lower so the bore line (buffer tube line) is against the body instead of floating in air and 3) reduce rearwards recoil push, as its whats actually causing the shooter to create muzzle rise from a gun that doesnt inherently exhibit any. I did do two flash hiding tests, in which many muzzle brakes and comps and hybrid devices appeared, so Id definitely suggest checking those out (theyre linked in the 2nd paragraph of this article). Finish:machined copper (as tested), also available Cerakoted, nitrided, and other finishes depending on metal Seems that most other shield systems degrade performance once the shield is applied. Fortis muzzle brake A2 was also in both flash hiding tests already (and I dont think there will be a third), as was the VooDoo Innovations Manimal, which is an extended-length A2 just like what youre talking about. Yea, OK, the reduction in recoil might be an issue on a .308/7.62. MSRP:$59.99. Finish:black (it looks parkerized) It's clean machining and jet black nitride finish sets it apart from the competition. No idea what the finish is or what it looked like when new, but most of its still hanging in there despite the high mileage on this muzzle device. Heres another candidate for shootout #4: If you havent done test #4 yet consider the Omega Mfg Super Compensator Muzzle Brake.Cost is an unbelieveable $19 and will outshine most of those $100+ brakes. AERO PRECISION. The M4-72 is smaller and lighter than the Titan, but it also spits more fire. It most certainly gets the job done in reducing felt recoil on your AR. There is nothing mechanical about the function of the firearm that causes the muzzle to go up. Im not saying thats how you should proceed, but thats definitely how most gun owners in CA proceed. although, now that Im looking at the photograph again (the brake went to Tyler Kee for use with his TBAC cans), it appears as though one of the suppressor mounting threads is squished, Material: steel At least prior to testing them it was my opinion that they were made to look cool and really nothing else, but it turns out they all performed admirably. core15 muzzle brakenaeyc teacher evaluation formsnaeyc teacher evaluation forms To the right of the shooter place a high speed video cam, let fly and record the results. The difference in porting is also noticed on the underside of the device where it has six valve holes to allow the fastest gasses reaching the second chamber to exit. Your brakes look cool and work very well. It doesnt hurt that its very cool looking without going overboard. We also crowned a new champion; one that Im going to have to purchase in case theres a test #4 in the cards. Diameter(at largest point): 0.747 Strike Industries King Comp The Strike Industries King Comp features a large dual chamber design, which was engineered to reduce felt recoil and help reduce the side concussion with specifically angled gas ports. Assim que ele cair, sua aposta ser perdida. Length:2.595 Feel free to brows our selection of Muzzle Devices below, or click here to view our Muzzle Brake, Compensator, Flash Hider Buyers Guide. As you can clearly see in the photo above, the ports are angled rearwards; a common theme among all of the top-performing brakes. There are some of those, but overall its a clean and consistent-looking piece. Last time I was there, I got assigned the bay next to a guy who was shooting an AR with a VG6 Epsilon. New suggestions Apparently they dont realize that the height of this rail is way lower than AR rail height, and it would be basically impossible to jury rig a sight onto this thing at a usable height. Ive been very excited to recoil test this flash hiding compensator since it nearly won Flash Hiding Test #2, despite nottechnically being just a flash hider. Reducing recoil by 72.65% was good enough for a fourth place finish (really, it was effectively in a tie for third). AR-15 Muzzle Brakes, Compensators & Flash Hiders. Test #4, then , The JP Standard and JP Recoil Eliminator brakes did well in the first test. When I do show up with my braked .338 WM, I tell people up and down the line how obnoxious my .338 will be. Diameter(at largest point): 1.009 If they persist, I do the work and deliver the lecture. Diameter(at largest point): 0.852 It just might make it civilized to shoot. Knight's Armament MAMS: The Multi-Axis Muzzle Stability (MAMS) brake from Knight's Armament may cost an arm and a leg, but it's also extremely expensive. core15 muzzle brake core15 muzzle brake. Theyre very effective if you are fortunate enough to have an AR capable of full-auto fire. No Change Tactical Advantage Armory BC-23 Compensator Hey Jeremy, interesting series. Light tool marks on the circumference, a couple nicks on the 90 edges, and one or two really small points where finish is missing. Link Update 1 or 3 The Atlas Blast Shield is compatible with all ODIN Works ATLAS Compensators. I realize theres A LOT of text in this article, but it did include: Note: there is no comparison whatsoever between the inch measurements in this test and those in the previous 5.56 tests (or the .30 cal test). On a .223/5.56 AR my preference is that I really dont want any downwards force on the muzzle at all. Weight:6.138oz New price $56.95 Apex Tactical Enhanced Stabilization Attachment It might be helpful down the road to swap gas blocks or rails without grinding off the Epsilon Has anyone tried the Faxon Slim Brakes?? Youre right about recoil not being just about rearward force (and Newtons 3rd Law of Motion) but rather how that force is distributed, aka the impact zone. The J-COMP concept comes from the Type 89 Japanese assault rifle used by the Japan Self-Defense Forces, the Japan Coast Guards Special Security Team units, and the Special Assault Team. so, like when are you going to provide any detail? For many newer builders, a flash hider is what first comes to mind when they think of a muzzle device. Sporting a proven design, these brakes redirect most of the gasses out to the side ports for reduced felt recoil. (Im aware it would most likely require threading at least some of the barrel end.). Heres my proposal : Take the best brake, say the M72, and several of best selling comps. Thats huge in competition, its fun when plinking, it can be important for multiple reasons when hunting, and its nice when target shooting. Put any muzzle device on that compensates for muzzle rise, though, and the muzzle will shoot downwards.
Marcus Luttrell Ranch, Articles C